Justice Isaac Lenaola’s Costly Mistake Comes Back to Haunt Him 12 Years Later

Image result for isaac lenaola

A Supreme court judge yesterday publicly apologised to an Intersex person for failing to protect his rights. Justice Isaac Lenaola admitted he did not understand issues affecting intersex persons when he presided over a criminal case against Richard Muasya, who was born with both male and female organs.

Muasya had been charged with robbery with violence at Kitui Chief Magistrate’s court in 2007. At the time, Lenaola was handling the case.

“At the time, I was completely unaware of the plight of intersex persons until Richard Muasya appeared in my court. I feel that we failed you because we could not make a decision. I personally apologise because I do not feel that I gave the case my best although I understand that a determination was later made after I left Kitui court,” said Lenaola.

Related image

He spoke when he came face to face with Muasya during the official launch of the final report of the taskforce on policy, legal, institutional and administrative reforms regarding the intersex persons in Kenya at a Nairobi hotel.

Muasya was born with both male and female genitalia and was unable to get a birth certificate, ID or any travel documents. He dropped out of school in Class Three and later got married but his marriage failed. The epitome of his troubles came when he was arrested and charged with robbery with violence. He was later convicted of the crime and sent to Kamiti Maximum Prison.

Here, male inmates sexually molested him and he moved to the High Court seeking to have his rights protected and to have a special prison for Intersex persons.

Although a three-judge bench awarded him Sh500, 000 for harassment, it did not agree that searches by prison warders were illegal and did not give consent to his request to have special prisons set up for intersex persons. He was later released because there was nowhere to keep him.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *