Sir Alex Ferguson is not only a United legend. But a legend of football, and a sporting legend, period. He is possibly the best football manager of all-time. His tenure from 1986-2013 brought immense success to the club, and helped United further its global standing, and boost the Premier League’s appeal.
This isn’t to be disrespectful to Sir Alex’s legacy or tenure. But his successor was David Moyes, who whilst performing well at Everton (a big and traditional club in its own right), he was unprepared to manage United, the biggest club in the United Kingdom.
Moreover, United at that point were champions. And it was always going to be hard for him. There is a strong case that Sir Alex himself chose Moyes to succeed him. This may have been well-intentioned. Though he apparently appeared out of his depth.
This may seem harsh to cite, overall. However, possibly a manager with more experience could have been better.
There are many factors as one can see causing United’s current mess.
But there could be specific people who could solve them:
Possibly somebody who is respected for speaking well, and being in the media, and has respect in the game in many quarters, could be an effective director of football.
It could even be a club legend.
It may not have to be a United legend, but somebody unrelated to the club.
My team is Arsenal, and I feel we’ve seen the experience United has had post-Sir Alex, and the club is looking to correct its own structure. Club CEO Ivan Gazidis said that the club, in May 2017, needed “catalyst for change”. This was roundly mocked in the early 17/18 season, but the appointments of Mislintat, Sanhelli, the moving on of Wenger, and the appointment of Emery, show a desire to change.
United needs similar, for sure. And who knows – if both clubs can change successfully, it may be pretty much a repeat of the epic battles of yesteryear. Even as a non-United fan, Arsenal and Man United share a lot of similarities, in both playing traditions, demands for success, trophy wins, and contributions to English football both on and off the pitch.