NHIF chief executive officer Geoffrey Mwangi and his co-accused Wilbert Kurgat were on Monday presented in court, with expectations that they would take plea, but do you know what? they failed to take plea to charges of conspiracy to defeat justice.
Appearing at a Milimani law court, the two objected to the charges, as proposed by the DPP, saying they are defective having failed to meet constitutional standards
The accused through their lawyers termed the charges as ambiguous and open-ended.
“All charges must contain sufficient information to enable accused persons to plead,” Ojienda said.
The suspects said they should be furnished with all information in order to answer to all charges.
The NHIF boss and the firm’s finance director Joseph Mbuvi were arrested on Friday for failure to provide documents required in a Sh100 million corruption case.
Mwangi said he is willing to show the court the alleged books if they are told which one in particular.
He said he was not the subject of the court order that is alleged to have been disobeyed.
The prosecution objected to the application for deferring of the plea taking.
Alexander Muteti told the court that Mwangi disobeyed a court order.
He said the two were subject to the said order and that they were served, yet they refused to supply payment vouchers.
Mwangi is represented by Prof Tom Ojienda, Migos Ogamba and three others.
Lawyer Jotham Arua, for the defence, said the two cannot plead to the charges as they are.
He said in order for them to respond to charges of failing to furnish a document to the investigators, the particular document must be indicated.
“They must also show that the order was served to the accused persons before the court,” he said.
Arua said disobedience cannot constitute a crime unless it’s willful, adding that the right to fair trial is paramount
After his arrest, Mwangi was grilled by detectives at the DCI headquarters along Kiambu Road for hours before being locked up at Muthaiga police station
The detectives have been combing documents at NHIF on allegations of financial misappropriation with regard to a digital payment system.