On Monday 15th, the all eyes turned to Paris as Notre Dame cathedral burned.
It was undoubtedly clear that it was difficult to put out the fire due to the complexity of the building, it’s age and density of timber used in constructing the structure.
However, it was unbelievable to watch that iconic structure come down, succumbing to the inferno easily as a grass thatched house, and it left so much for us to discern.
Sometime we are helpless
First, watching this ancient iconic temple covered in smoke and heat with no possible help, was a frightening reminder there are many forces out there that render us powerless to save something dear to us, and all we can do is watch helplessly.
Nothing is permanent
Paris is the most-visited city in the world and this means that the world is much connected to Paris. As such, people have memories of Notre Dame, memories that were dusted with ash and debris in yesterday’s horrific scene, teaching us that nothing is permanent.
There will always be critics
As is often the case, those notorious critics were everywhere, criticizing the mourners. “Remind everyone that the church was just bricks and mortar”. Possibly, others would argue that art is “just paint on a canvas” and that their children are “just smaller people who look like me and live in my house.” its a clear lesson that people will never feel the same way as you, as long as you now walking in the same shoes.
The world has sufficient wealth
Within hours of the church coming down, two of France’s wealthiest families — led by François-Henri Pinault and Bernard Arnault — had pledged no less than €300million in funding for the restoration effort. The city of Paris was also able to mobilize €10million.
Arnault is the CEO of LVMH, the world’s largest luxury-goods company, the richest person in Europe and the fourth-richest person in the world according to Forbes magazine, with a net worth of $91.3 billion, as of April 2019. The best-known brand featured by Arnault is Louis Vuitton, Handbags, suitcases, you know the ones.
By comparison, Pinault is worth a paltry €30billion. He’s more of a Gucci man, and he also owns Stade Rennais FC.
Between them, they have significantly more money than several European states — such as Croatia, Serbia, Slovakia or Slovenia.
Something to think about.
The financial role that the Catholic Church could play in the restoration has not been mentioned. Nobody outside the Vatican truly knows how much money the church has, but in 2012 The Economist calculated that the Vatican’s operating budget in the US alone came to $170billion. It stands to reason, then, that the global figure would be much larger again.
Pope Francis has confirmed that he is praying for all those affected by the Notre Dame fire. That is to say, he is putting his hands together, rather than in his pocket.
This will come as no surprise to anyone who has ever had to raise a few hundred or a few thousand euro to renovate a church in suburban or rural Ireland without the help from the Vatican’s bajillions.
It would be incredibly cheap to suggest that it is in some way wrong to give money for the restoration. There is a value that transcends simple economics in restoring testaments to civilization. Better that, Notre Dame remains a symbol of European history than €300 million rests in a billionaire’s bank account.
People selectively respond to emergencies
But the immediacy and magnitude of their response tells us something very important about the society we live in.
If two men in a world of more than 7 billion people can provide €300million to restore Notre Dame, within six hours, then there is enough money in the world to feed every mouth, shelter every family and educate every child. The failure to do so is a matter of will, and a matter of system.
The failure to do so comes from our failure to recognize the unexciting emergencies that claim lives all around us every single day.
Works of art and architectural history and beauty rely on the ingenuity of people, and it is people who must be protected above all else.
Brick and mortar and stained-glass might burn, but they do not bleed, and they do not starve, and they do not suffer. Humans suffer.
France currently counts 140,000 homeless people — 30,000 of whom are children. A 2018 report by the Secours Catholique revealed that in total there are around 8.8 million people living below the poverty line in France in 2017.
This means they are living on an income of less than €1,026 a month, and many of them live on considerably less. One in every eight French people
The next time someone tries to pretend like you need to choose between homelessness or immigration, nurses’ pay or a tax cut, a children’s hospital or a motorway, remember this moment. The money is there at a click of a finger. It just isn’t in our hands.